Self-Consensus Fails as a Reliable Early-Exit Signal for Reasoning Models
September 10, 2026
A study of 3,520 consensus rules across two models found that stopping inference when partial trajectories agree leads to incorrect answers. While consensus can save 32% of tokens, it fails to distinguish between completed reasoning and persistent errors, unlike the proposed DEER boundary-confidence control.
HOW THIS AFFECTS YOU
●
builderYou should avoid using simple consensus-based early exits to reduce inference costs, as they risk high error rates.
●
researcherThe consensus-termination gap demonstrates that agreement is not a proxy for reasoning completion.