Critique of Functional Valence Claims in Large Language Models
October 28, 2026
The paper argues that current empirical evidence fails to distinguish functional valence in LLMs from simple preferences, value judgments, or role-playing. It identifies critical gaps in how LLM states are tested against cognitive science definitions of pleasure and pain.
HOW THIS AFFECTS YOU
●
researcherYou should reconsider whether your current benchmarks actually measure valence or just preference behaviors.
●
policyThis suggests caution when evaluating LLM safety frameworks based on simulated emotional states.