The Silent Cost of Artificial Intelligence Assistance: A Theory of Autonomy Surrender, the Recovery Mechanism, and the Restoration of Human Agency

Autonomy surrender is framed here as a measurable, cumulative process where repeated AI assistance depletes cognitive bandwidth incrementally until reclaiming independent judgment becomes psychologically difficult — a threshold effect the authors call the surrender threshold. The paper builds on the HIAG framework to argue that AI system designers carry an ethical obligation to actively support human re-entry into decision loops, not just permit it. Practitioners building AI-assisted workflows should note the implication: passive opt-out mechanisms are insufficient if users have already crossed the surrender threshold.