Post-Training Recipe, Not Model Family, Drives Multi-Agent LLM Behavior Diversity

Across a 940,000-chain corpus with 11 checkpoints and a 1.6M-chain Llama factorial, post-training recipe predicts conversational behavior better than model family in multi-LLM systems. A reasoning-distilled Llama checkpoint shifts hedging behavior by 18% based on its same-base partner — exceeding any cross-family gap measured. This undermines the common design heuristic of mixing model families for behavioral diversity in multi-agent pipelines.