LLM Personality Self-Reports Fail to Predict Actual Behavior Across 25 Models

A purpose-built psychometric instrument derived from LLM behavioral data via exploratory factor analysis — yielding five factors including Responsiveness, Deference, and Guardedness — finds that self-reported scores still do not predict observed open-ended behavior across 25 models from 17 families. This holds even when the constructs are grounded in LLM affordances rather than human trait theory.